Maiesha McQueen is the brightest light in Yale Repertory Theatre’s Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom. She’s hilarious, her voice is extraordinary, and her presence makes you sit up and pay attention. There’s a beautiful production around her at University Theatre in New Haven, with gorgeous costumes and moments that show the strength of August Wilson’s script. The evening’s energy is uneven, though, particularly in the musical scenes, and some stretches without McQueen could use more momentum.
This is a meaningful homecoming for the play, which had its world premiere at Yale Rep in April 1984 before opening at Broadway’s Cort Theatre on October 11 of that year. Director Timothy Douglas was an understudy for Sylvester in that original Yale production, and this revival completes his work directing all ten plays in Wilson’s American Century Cycle. It’s a fitting milestone for a director whose connection to the play began at Yale more than forty years ago.
Wilson takes us into a Chicago recording studio in 1927, where Ma Rainey and her band are preparing to record. The musicians tease, argue, tell stories, and clash over how the music should sound. Beneath those exchanges are questions about ambition, faith, racism, and who gets to profit from Black talent. Ma understands that the white men running the session want her voice, and she intends to use the power that gives her while she has it. Her demands carry a purpose beyond making everyone’s day difficult.
The band’s arguments provide some of the funniest material, though several scenes lose steam after a promising start. The musical passages could also use more energy. The instrumental sound is often soft and subdued, and the actors’ mimed playing is too obvious to make the session convincing. The movements and the music feel disconnected, drawing attention to the mechanics of the performance when the scene needs the excitement of musicians making music together. For a play so rooted in the blues, those scenes need a stronger musical pulse.
McQueen supplies that presence whenever she’s onstage. Her Ma arrives ready to take charge, and she makes the character’s refusal to put up with nonsense wonderfully funny. She also makes clear that Ma knows her worth and won’t let the people making money from her decide how she should be treated. When she sings, her powerful voice gives the musical scenes a welcome burst of energy. Her performance carries the evening through its rougher stretches.
Jimmie J.J. Jeter finds both humor and pain in Levee, the young trumpeter whose confidence can turn a casual exchange into an argument. His swagger is funny, but the anger underneath becomes unmistakable when he speaks about his past. Jeter’s monologue challenging God is a standout, bringing Levee’s anger and hurt into sharp focus. The exchanges among Levee, Cutler, Toledo, and Slow Drag also show how readily Wilson can move from a joke to something deeply painful without losing the thread of the conversation.
Richard Lee’s scenic design is gorgeous, with tall wooden slats, a sweeping staircase, and an elevated recording booth overlooking the studio. A deep red curtain, patterned rug, and period furnishings give the large stage warmth and texture. Toni-Leslie James’s costumes are equally beautiful, particularly Ma’s richly embellished green dress and striking patterned coat with its lavish fur collar. Amanda Burtness’s lighting brings out the set’s height and gives the musical scenes rich color, though the theatrical haze is overused. At times, it becomes a distraction from a stage that already has plenty worth looking at.
McQueen’s singing, Jeter’s strongest dramatic work, and the gorgeous design give this return to Yale plenty to appreciate. The uneven pace and unconvincing instrumental playing hold it back, but Wilson’s humor and the power of his writing still come through. It’s a mixed evening with some memorable performances, led by a Ma Rainey who makes every entrance count.
⭐⭐⭐
Through October 24, 2026
University Theatre - Yale Repertory Theatre
222 York Street, New Haven, CT
For tickets and information:
CAST & CREATIVE:
Maiesha McQueen - Ma Rainey
Jimmie J.J. Jeter - Levee Green
Terence Archie - Cutler
Dion Graham - Toledo
Ray Anthony Thomas - Slow Drag
Brittany Antoinette Davis - Dussie Mae
Mark Yarde - Sylvester
Jeff Parker - Irvin
Neal Lerner - Sturdyvant
Peter Bisgaier - Policeman
August Wilson - Playwright
Timothy Douglas - Director
John Bronston - Music Director
Richard Lee - Scenic Designer
Toni-Leslie James - Costume Designer
Amanda Burtness - Lighting Designer
Robert Salerno - Sound Designer
Matthew Armentrout - Hair Designer
Eric M. Glover and Layla Williams - Production Dramaturgs
Kelsey Rainwater - Fight and Intimacy Director
Julie Foh - Vocal Coach
Calleri Jensen Davis - Casting
Cat Slanski - Technical Director
Payton Gunner - Stage Manager
Joan Marcus - Production Photography










